Tuft + Paw now offers three Really Great Cat Litter formulas. The useful choice is not simply “tofu versus clay”; it is scent preference, odor needs, disposal rules, box compatibility, and recurring cost.

How we evaluated it

We reviewed the official formula details, ingredients, bag size, price, subscription terms, disposal guidance, and compatibility notes. This is desk research, not a hands-on litter trial.

The short answer

Really Great Cat Litter is most compelling for households prioritizing a lightweight bag, low-tracking pellet format, and a choice between unscented, lavender, or stronger odor-control formulas. It is less convincing for shoppers who need the lowest possible cost, prefer fine-grain litter, or use an automatic box that requires a different litter texture.

BEST FIT

Choose it when

You want lightweight tofu pellets, prefer an unscented option, and can follow the disposal and litter-box guidance for the exact formula.

THINK TWICE

Skip or compare alternatives when

Your priority is the lowest recurring price, your cat rejects pellets, or your automatic litter box requires fine clumping litter.

Which formula fits?

PURE TOFU

Unscented charcoal

The everyday option for households avoiding added scent. The brand lists activated carbon in the formula.

PURE TOFU

Lavender

The same core format with dried lavender petals. Scent-sensitive cats may still prefer unscented litter.

MIXED TOFU

OdorStop

Targets multi-cat odor with tofu, pea, and bentonite components. The brand specifically says not to flush this formula.

The tradeoffs that matter

  1. Tracking and dust: the low-tracking and 99% dust-free statements are manufacturer claims; real results depend on the cat, mat, and box.
  2. Automatic boxes: Tuft + Paw warns that pellet litter may not work reliably in many self-cleaning boxes designed for fine clay litter.
  3. Disposal: even when a litter is described as flushable, check municipal rules, plumbing guidance, and cat-waste restrictions. OdorStop is not recommended for flushing.
  4. True monthly cost: one bag is described as roughly one month for one cat, but depth, box size, and use can change that.
APPROVED AFFILIATE OFFER

Really Great Cat Litter

Choose Unscented or Lavender and confirm current multipack and subscription pricing.

Check the official offer Affiliate link. We may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
APPROVED AFFILIATE OFFER

Really Great Cat Litter OdorStop

The mixed-tofu option for stronger odor control in busy or multi-cat boxes.

Check the OdorStop offer Affiliate link. Price and availability can change.

Keep comparing